Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo

OPINIONS

Wed 09 Apr 2025 11:11 am - Jerusalem Time

Israeli Newspaper: The prospect of a new nuclear agreement could spark deep concern in Jerusalem

Michael Oren

My mother, a seasoned family therapist, used to say, "The apparent problem is not the real problem." That is, matters that appear more urgent are often used to mask a deeper, more threatening problem. This was the case with the hastily convened emergency summit between President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu.

The apparent problem was the trade tariffs imposed by the United States on Israel. It is true that they are serious and could cost Israel more than $2 billion at a time when it cannot afford such losses. However, the tariffs were not the reason Netanyahu rushed to Washington. The real problem is Iran.

During the two leaders' joint press conference yesterday in the Oval Office, Trump surprised his guest with a brief announcement: "We are in direct talks with Iran." It is important to note that the US president has never hidden his desire to talk with Iran. Indeed, immediately upon his return to the White House last January, he sent a letter to Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, inviting him to resume talks. But Trump has now revealed that the talks are at their peak, announcing that "there will be a very big meeting" next Saturday. Most surprisingly, these talks are direct between the United States and Iran.

This step was not dared by President Biden, who had hoped to revive the 2015 agreement. Biden's negotiating team refrained from meeting directly with the Iranians, using intermediaries to convey messages.

It is highly likely that Israel was aware of these direct talks, and Netanyahu did not publicly oppose them in his Oval Office statements. Nevertheless, the prospect of a new nuclear agreement is causing deep concern in Jerusalem. The key questions are: How long will the talks take? What is their ultimate goal? Is the goal to reach an agreement that is slightly better than the 2015 agreement, limited to a temporary freeze on Iran's nuclear program? And, ultimately, what will the United States' position be if the talks fail? These questions are of paramount importance to Israel's security. The Iranians are experts at negotiations and will almost certainly try to extend them as long as possible to allow Russia to repair and improve their air defense systems, which the Israeli Air Force destroyed. They will likely agree to a slightly better deal than the 2015 agreement, but they will retain their nuclear infrastructure and reactors. They will demand the lifting of the harsh sanctions reimposed by Trump and the removal of the credible military threat that has been put back on the table.

While Israel works to resolve the apparent issue of tariffs, it must focus on obtaining answers to the real problem: renewed talks between the United States and Iran. We must obtain clear guarantees regarding the talks and their ultimate goals. We must make clear that the only agreement Israel will accept is one that dismantles Iran's nuclear infrastructure, not one that merely freezes it.

Only such an agreement can guarantee Israel's vital security interests and consolidate its military achievements in the region. It must be emphasized that only such an agreement serves the interests of Israel and the entire Middle East, as well as those of the United States itself.

Tags

Share your opinion

Israeli Newspaper: The prospect of a new nuclear agreement could spark deep concern in Jerusalem

MORE FROM OPINIONS

Between Belfast and Gaza: Lessons from Northern Ireland for Palestinians

Palestine: From Partition to Ethnic Cleansing... The Nakba Continues

Rafat Qassis

Trump's Tour: Winners and Losers

Awni Al-Mashni

Every day in the camp is a reminder that the Nakba is not over.

Muhammad Abu Akar, a former prisoner who spent five years in administrative detention.

On the 77th anniversary of the Nakba: Escalation against UNRWA and restrictions on refugee camps...

This message may never arrive.

The End of the Global Aid Industry

Foreign Affairs

The release of Eidans...is there a breakthrough that will stop the genocide?

Jamal Zaqout

The release of Idan Alexander: New implications for US politics and Israeli relations

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Israel at a Crossroads: Occupation, Genocide, and the Death of a Vision

Alon Ben-Meir

Between Friedman's speech and Trump's interests, Palestine is a national liberation issue, not a bargaining...

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Doubts about the intentions and feasibility of the US aid plan for Gaza!

Nabhan Khreisha

All efforts to stop the war of extermination and thwart the plans for displacement and...

Walid Al-Awad

In the dialectic of primary and secondary contradiction

Mohsen Abu Ramadan

An entire family in the grip of absence... when the sky bombards memory

Ben Maamar Al-Hajj Issa is an Algerian writer and researcher.

The attack on Jerusalem intensifies, extends and expands

Rasim Obeidat

This Israeli government is not our ally.

Trump's plan... under a humanitarian cover

Trump's fantasy and speculation about the upcoming announcement

Urgent political transformations