Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo

OPINIONS

Sat 08 Mar 2025 9:43 am - Jerusalem Time

To control the West Bank!

Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank is a highly complex issue that touches on international law, Palestinian rights, and regional politics. Under international law, the West Bank has been occupied territory since 1967, and its fate must be determined through negotiations. Voting or discussing Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank in an Israeli-only framework ignores Palestinian rights and UN resolutions that consider settlements illegal and call for a two-state solution. Such a discussion, if conducted without genuine Palestinian participation, would be a unilateral move that would increase tensions, rather than pursue a just political solution.

The problem is that “next Sunday, the bill to apply Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank is scheduled to be discussed in the Ministerial Committee for Legislative Affairs, where the campaign is led by Knesset members from the Otzma Yehudit party, and here in this descriptive analysis we will examine the legality of this measure.”

Legally, this procedure is in conflict with international law, but it is carried out within the framework of the internal Israeli legal system. Here is an explanation of the legal dimensions:

1- According to international law:

• The West Bank is considered occupied territory under UN resolutions and the Geneva Conventions, and therefore Israel does not have the legal right to impose its sovereignty over it unilaterally.

• Security Council Resolution 242 (1967) affirms the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by force, which applies to the West Bank.

• Security Council Resolution 2334 (2016) condemns settlements and considers them a violation of international law, meaning that the imposition of Israeli sovereignty would also be internationally illegal.

2- From the Israeli side:

The Knesset and the government can debate any bill, but passing it will not change the international legal status, but rather will be a domestic political move aimed at consolidating Israeli control over the West Bank. Israel has previously annexed East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights through unilateral decisions, but the international community has not recognized these decisions.

3- Possible repercussions:

Any move to annex the West Bank could lead to a dangerous escalation, whether within the Palestinian territories or at the diplomatic level with the countries of the world, and could result in international punitive measures against Israel, especially from the European Union or other countries that oppose the annexation, which could undermine any future possibility of a two-state solution.

The procedure is not legal according to international law, but it is possible within the Israeli political system, especially in the midst of Israeli disputes over the dismissal of the legal advisor and the targeting of the judicial system in Israel by extremists, although it may lead to serious consequences on the political, legal and security levels.

Addressing this situation:

Preventing this action requires action on several levels:

1- Palestinian level

Intensify diplomatic efforts: The Palestinian Authority must move quickly to the United Nations, the Security Council, and the European Union to request a clear condemnation of this project as a violation of international law.

Unifying the internal ranks: The Palestinian division weakens any international position, so achieving national unity may increase the ability to confront this step effectively. Activating peaceful popular resistance and organizing peaceful protests and movements on the ground may put pressure on Israel and attract the attention of the international community.

2- Arab and Islamic level

The Arab and Islamic countries, especially those that have relations with Israel, such as the UAE, Bahrain, Jordan and Egypt, are moving to pressure Tel Aviv to stop any steps towards annexation, and to activate the role of the Arab League and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation in issuing decisions and taking diplomatic measures against Israel.

3- International level

Escalating the file to the Security Council and the United Nations to impose sanctions or issue resolutions against Israel if it continues with this approach, to pressure the European Union to oppose any annexation step, and this can be used to impose sanctions or freeze economic agreements with Israel, legal action to file complaints with the International Court of Justice or the International Criminal Court against Israeli officials who push for annexation.

4- The internal Israeli level

Supporting opposing Israeli voices: There are Israeli parties and organizations that reject annexation for fear of its security and diplomatic repercussions. These voices can be supported internationally and in the media. Israel can be warned of the consequences if it becomes clear that this step will lead to international isolation. The Israeli government may back down from it, as happened in some previous attempts.

The confrontation requires a unified Palestinian move, Arab and Islamic pressure, activating international channels, and using legal and diplomatic tools to prevent this step before it becomes a reality.


........

The bill to apply Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank is scheduled to be discussed next Sunday in the Ministerial Committee for Legislative Affairs, where the campaign is led by Knesset members from the Otzma Yehudit party.

Tags

Share your opinion

To control the West Bank!

MORE FROM OPINIONS

Between Belfast and Gaza: Lessons from Northern Ireland for Palestinians

Palestine: From Partition to Ethnic Cleansing... The Nakba Continues

Rafat Qassis

Trump's Tour: Winners and Losers

Awni Al-Mashni

Every day in the camp is a reminder that the Nakba is not over.

Muhammad Abu Akar, a former prisoner who spent five years in administrative detention.

On the 77th anniversary of the Nakba: Escalation against UNRWA and restrictions on refugee camps...

This message may never arrive.

The End of the Global Aid Industry

Foreign Affairs

The release of Eidans...is there a breakthrough that will stop the genocide?

Jamal Zaqout

The release of Idan Alexander: New implications for US politics and Israeli relations

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Israel at a Crossroads: Occupation, Genocide, and the Death of a Vision

Alon Ben-Meir

Between Friedman's speech and Trump's interests, Palestine is a national liberation issue, not a bargaining...

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Doubts about the intentions and feasibility of the US aid plan for Gaza!

Nabhan Khreisha

All efforts to stop the war of extermination and thwart the plans for displacement and...

Walid Al-Awad

In the dialectic of primary and secondary contradiction

Mohsen Abu Ramadan

An entire family in the grip of absence... when the sky bombards memory

Ben Maamar Al-Hajj Issa is an Algerian writer and researcher.

The attack on Jerusalem intensifies, extends and expands

Rasim Obeidat

This Israeli government is not our ally.

Trump's plan... under a humanitarian cover

Trump's fantasy and speculation about the upcoming announcement

Urgent political transformations