OPINIONS
Sun 24 Mar 2024 9:14 pm - Jerusalem Time
Zionism will never be viewed the same after the Gaza genocide
By Phil Weiss
This is a problem all across the country. And I hope the president and Blinken can get this thing calmed down because if it doesn’t get calmed down before the Democratic convention, it’s going to be a very ugly time in Chicago. I promise you that. No matter what happens, I know it’s a huge problem.” Last week, Brad Sherman, the Israel-loving Congress member from Los Angeles, fought back, accusing “anti-Israel forces” of an “attempt to penetrate and muddy our national discourse.” But a week later, Sherman was running through the Capitol as protesters from the antiwar group Code Pink held up bloodied hands before him.
Sherman accused them of antisemitism. “There’s blood on your hands for the genocide—you’re trying to kill every Jew.” That is the chief refuge for Democrats who excuse Israel’s actions. To say that critics of genocide are motivated by antisemitism. But even liberal media are giving a platform to progressive critics. “The United States is complicit in genocide,” Mehdi Hasan said this week on New York public radio, and when the host pushed back and said Hasan was not blaming Hamas, Hasan said of course he denounces Hamas, but his tax dollars are not going to support Hamas.
He also pointed out the inevitable consequences of military occupation. “The oppressed will always rise against the oppressor.” And in wonderful media news this week, Atlantic editor Jeffrey Goldberg withdrew from a speaking engagement in Kentucky after students questioned his record in the Israeli military nearly 40 years ago. Jeffrey Goldberg, Editor-in-Chief of The Atlantic, withdrew from a scheduled speaking event at the University of Kentucky (UK) Wednesday, citing a last-minute schedule change, amidst concerns from students about his past as a former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) prison guard and his views on Zionism…. “We were informed that students expressed concern as to why a former IDF prison guard would be speaking on democracy and journalism at an event celebrating the integration of UK. Students were told he withdrew to not cause harm on campus,” the representative [of a Palestinian solidarity group] stated.
The event was billed as “The Future of Journalism and the Health of Our Democracy.” That’s a little bit of accountability. The editor of the Atlantic is finally being called out for his service for Israel. The writer Yakov Hirsch repeatedly explained on our site that Netanyahu could not have maintained his faultless reputation in the U.S. mainstream without Goldberg fostering “hasbara culture.” And bear in mind, that Goldberg used to brag about his military service. He wrote a whole memoir about it. Now, times are changing. And other editors who carried water for Israel will surely be called on to defend that work.
This process is just beginning. Zionists still have esteem in the U.S. discourse. The view that Israel supporters promote bigotry against Palestinians is still off-limits. Even as mainstream Jewish organizations assert that those who support Palestinian rights are bigoted against Jews. “Israel supporters should be seen as on the same moral level as supporters of Bull Connor, but in the U.S. and Western mainstream you can only point to antisemitism— you can never point to anti-Palestinian racism on the Israel side,” Donald Johnson has written on our site. “We cannot make progress on this issue if the extreme racism of the pro-genocide side is never discussed. People have to be able to say that any group, whether white southerners or South Africans or Nation of Islam members or Christian evangelical Zionists or Germans or, yes, Jewish supporters of Israel, can be racists. They can make racism central to their ideology. But Zionist racism is still a taboo subject, automatically branded as antisemitic, because fundamentally Palestinians are seen as lesser.” Progressives are actively taking on that discrimination. Please join that effort!
Tags
MORE FROM OPINIONS
Gaza: October 7 in historical perspective
YAANI.fr -Translation for "Al-Quds" dot com
Sermon for Gaza
CHRIS HEDGES
"The Palestinian political class as an obstacle to the revival of the national situation"
Dr. Ibrahim Abrash
What Columbia’s Protests Reveal About America
Foreign Affairs
THOMAS FRIEDMAN: Israel has a choice to make - Rafah or Riyadh
The New York Times
Across the Western world, public opinion on Palestine is finally shifting
Aljazeera
War on Gaza: Labour or Tories, the UK will always back Israel
Middle East Eye
War on Gaza: Why are students protesting at campuses across the US?
Middle East Eye
Is the sun slowly setting on U.S. power? That depends on us.
The Washington Post
Why Egypt has been missing in action during Israel's war on Gaza
New Arab
Hebrew Newspaper: Iran feels that it is immune, but it made a big mistake in confronting Israel
CH12
Revolt in the Universities
CHRIS HEDGES
Is an Anti-Iran Alliance Emerging in the Middle East?
Foreign Affairs
China’s Alternative Order
Foreign Affairs
How an ‘antisemitism hoax' drowned out the discovery of mass graves in Gaza
Middle East Eye
It’s time to declare Israel a rogue state
Aljazeera
Ilan Pappe: Zionism is near its end
Middle East Eye
Washington has lost touch with reality. If it doesn't adapt, the world will pay
Middle East Eye
We need an exodus from Zionism
The Guardian
How European nationalism and Zionism crushed the Arab-Jewish alliance
New Arab
Share your opinion
Zionism will never be viewed the same after the Gaza genocide