Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo

OPINIONS

Sun 27 Apr 2025 8:34 am - Jerusalem Time

How do you see my driving? Our trust in your leadership was misplaced!



Awni Al-Mashni


If opposition in poetry is for a poet to write a poem that imitates another poem with the same rhyme and meter, and with a level no less than the first poem, then I permit myself, in the same sense, to write an article in which I oppose the article of my creative journalist friend Ibrahim Melhem, “How Do You View My Leadership?” with my conviction that I will not respond to the second condition, which is to imitate his article, in idea, language, and meaning.

I tried to imagine the answer, and I was guided by their influence. I didn't need to ask a friend for help, or delete two answers, or even ask the audience for help, as George Qardahi did in his famous program "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?" I was guided by "the dung that leads to the camel," as I tried to revive my imagination by contemplating the facts of objective reality.

We were promised a state, but the West Bank became too cramped for its inhabitants, turning it into racial ghettos. We were promised Singapore, but we became Somalia. We were promised democracy, but we became a democracy where slaves choose their masters. We were promised a state of law, but we became Saxonian law. We were promised a fair distribution of opportunities, but we became a fair distribution of opportunities and sacrifices together: opportunities for one group and not others, and sacrifices for another group and not others.

This is the empty half of the cup. The other half has been filled with our blood in the Gaza Strip. The screams of children in the Gaza Strip tell a different story. They say that many calculations were absent, hasty calculations, and romantic calculations. The nobility of the goal does not justify the errors in the calculations, and the saying "the honor of trying is enough for us" does not apply. The attempt, even if it is honorable, takes us to a place far beyond the borders of the homeland.

"How do you see my leadership?" Your leadership is land being stolen, blood being shed, poverty being rampant, and homes being demolished.

"How do you see my leadership?" Our trust in your leadership was misplaced. Our people were shouting at the top of their voices from inside the bus: Stop, stop, stop. We are on the edge of the abyss. Any movement could lead us to a complete collapse, and then no one will be saved.

"How do you see my driving?" You've lost control of the brakes, the steering wheel, everything. You're not driving the bus. The bus drives itself by its own acceleration. Enough!

"How do you see my leadership?" Your leadership did not take us to the final station, it did not bring us closer to the final station, it did not leave us where we were. Rather, it took us far beyond the final station.

"How do you like my driving?" Stop it, at the first stop, stop, get up from the driver's seat, let's manage to find a more knowledgeable and more professional driver.

Tags

Share your opinion

How do you see my driving? Our trust in your leadership was misplaced!

MORE FROM OPINIONS

Between ideology and pragmatism... it is time to save what remains of Palestine

Ramallah - "Al-Quds" Dot Com

Between Belfast and Gaza: Lessons from Northern Ireland for Palestinians

Palestine: From Partition to Ethnic Cleansing... The Nakba Continues

Rafat Qassis

Trump's Tour: Winners and Losers

Awni Al-Mashni

Every day in the camp is a reminder that the Nakba is not over.

Muhammad Abu Akar, a former prisoner who spent five years in administrative detention.

On the 77th anniversary of the Nakba: Escalation against UNRWA and restrictions on refugee camps...

This message may never arrive.

The End of the Global Aid Industry

Foreign Affairs

The release of Eidans...is there a breakthrough that will stop the genocide?

Jamal Zaqout

The release of Idan Alexander: New implications for US politics and Israeli relations

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Israel at a Crossroads: Occupation, Genocide, and the Death of a Vision

Alon Ben-Meir

Between Friedman's speech and Trump's interests, Palestine is a national liberation issue, not a bargaining...

Marwan Emil Toubasi

Doubts about the intentions and feasibility of the US aid plan for Gaza!

Nabhan Khreisha

All efforts to stop the war of extermination and thwart the plans for displacement and...

Walid Al-Awad

In the dialectic of primary and secondary contradiction

Mohsen Abu Ramadan

An entire family in the grip of absence... when the sky bombards memory

Ben Maamar Al-Hajj Issa is an Algerian writer and researcher.

The attack on Jerusalem intensifies, extends and expands

Rasim Obeidat

This Israeli government is not our ally.

Trump's plan... under a humanitarian cover

Trump's fantasy and speculation about the upcoming announcement